The mugging of a priest was the most horrifying thing Pierce had ever seen. It was the type of fear that convinced him he was dreaming. What shook him awake was the gunshot. He was in his car smoking a joint, across the street from a church, when two bald Mexicans approached the priest.
The priest smiled at the muggers until they pointed a demanding gun at his face. The wallet, he said with integrity bogged by fear, had money only for those who needed it. The muggers tried coercing the priest with expletives, threats, and barrel jabs to the chin, but the priest did not relent. Instead, he sobbed, threw up choking on his coughs, and cried loudly, repeating that he didn’t want to die like a child whose broken toy was snatched from him. This was what terrified Pierce. A priest shouldn’t be afraid to die, but this priest was and he did, leaving only an emptying, ransacked body.
He drove home slowly, taking back streets and winding to avoid street lights. Once home, he put the milk in the fridge, showered, and told his wife what he saw.
“What were you doing across a church,” she asked.
“Smoking.”
“Weed?”
“Yeah,” he said. His voice was colorless. “They took around a thousand bucks from his wallet.”
“1,000? How do you figure?”
“The guy with the gun counted ten bills. They looked like 100s.”
“You must have been thirty feet away. In the dark. High. They could have been 1s,” she said.
“Why would they count 1s?” He paused to find an answer to his question. “I saw a man die, Brenda!” His breaths came in an exaggerated staccato.
“Feel,” she said suddenly excited, and guided his hand to her stomach. “It’s moving!”
“He is six weeks old. He is incapable of movement and I just realized I didn’t call the police! Should I call the police?”
“You wouldn’t be so worried if you hadn’t been smoking out,” she said.
He forgot about the murder while arguing with his wife. What pregnant woman craves just milk, he asked himself. Eventually, in a way that made sense only to him, he decided he should have a glass of milk and a pickle. He decided it was the most delicious thing he’d eaten. His wife gagged a little watching him from the couch. He looked at his meal as though he were staring into the universe.
The next morning, his wife hobbled into the kitchen while he cooked breakfast. “Can you put a little milk in the eggs,” she asked.
“Yeah,” he said and his mind drifted as he stirred the eggs. Mm, milk. Milk is so delicious. Why am I craving pickles. Milk pickle. I love milk pickle-church-priest—. “Oh my God, I witnessed a murder last night.” He plated the eggs. Half landed on the counter with his mind focused in recollection.
“They’re burned,” she said, poking at the rubber eggs with her finger.
His thoughts raced faster than his words. In his mind, the conversation was at a point where he should be yelling. “The killers? How do you know! Tell me!” he said.
“No, the eggs. I thought you were joking about the priest. Did you really see someone die?” She asked with the tone of a mother comforting her son.
Before he could answer, their ears perked at what they heard on the television: “Dirty priest gunned down in marijuana deal gone awry. Story at noon.” The priest, the news anchor revealed ten minutes later, was discovered by a six year old girl who, in her excitement to attend church, ran from the parking lot to the front of the building. A search of the area found a half-smoked joint filled with top grade marijuana estimated to cost 700 dollars an ounce.
“700 dollars, Pierce! You spent 700! On weed?” Brenda said, pointing her fork like a trident.
“I stole it actually.”
“Stole it?”
“From a kid,” he said, eating eggs off the counter. “Flashed my Halloween badge. Scared kids’ll do anything for adults.”
The anchor continued and explained that the situation of the priest’s death spurred further investigation. The church, it turns out, was a front, and its sound-proof basement was filled with women, beaten on the outside as well as on the inside for fifty dollars (or five per thrust, one said in broken English, eyes to her feet). “In other news,” the anchor said, “a man impersonating a police officer was reported to have robbed a local elementary student.”
“Shit, Brenda, I feel awful,” he said. “I’m scared. I’m really, really scared”
“The kid won’t remember you. He was probably high, too.”
“Not that,” he said washing the dishes. “It’s how the priest died, and his crying. I need to talk to one.” He left for the nearest church after showering. He fought his way through the exiting congregation as though walking into a sentient wave frantic to reach land. He explained to the priest what he saw and who he was.
“Wait, that was your joint,” the priest asked with roadie enthusiasm. “You’re a community hero, man! Like Batman!”
“I actually came to talk to you about the priest who died. Or about yourself, too. You believe in heaven, right?”
“Yes.”
“Are you afraid of dying?”
“Fuck yes.”
“But you just said you believe in heaven,” Pierce said feeling witty like a law student at a party.
“Look, man, I get about two of you per week asking why I’m afraid of dying. I tell them all the same thing: I don’t fucking know. Usually it’s a teenager, usually they’re high—you’re not high right now, are you?”
“No.”
“—and usually I tell them to go read the Bible. They do, and sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn’t. All I’ll tell you is that I became a priest because I can’t get it up.”
“That’s . . . I don’t know what that is,” he said. He kept pulling the padded knee-rest from below the seat in front of him with his foot. He had absolutely nothing to say, and, after the third time he pulled the knee-rest down, he felt awkward. Given the setting, he felt the urge to pray for the priest to say something, but he didn’t have to.
“Your wife was in here last week. She asked me to bless It in her stomach.”
“You mean our son,” Pierce corrected.
“Yeah, that. And you. She asked to bless you, too,” the priest said, flipping through a hymn book. “I hate this song.”
“Did she ask you to bless her?”
“Nah. Listen, I gotta do stuff. You and your wife should stop by next weekend. It’s a great community and it would be great to have a fellow smoker in the congregation. 700 bucks, eh? Nice. Keep this between us, please.”
A family approached him before he walked through a door near the back. He responded to their questions as they expected him to. He was convincingly graceful, soft, and well-spoken.
When he got home, Pierce cooked his wife a brunch she ate like a duck. He spied on her as she ate while he pretended to read. She asked what the hell he was staring at and he put his hand on the bump of her belly. “I can feel him move,” he said sincerely.
“That’s just gas,” she said through a mouthful of bacon.
He smiled and cleaned up after his wife. When he was done, he went to the backyard and smoked another joint and thought about both priests, his wife, and what he hoped would be a boy. He thought about how he would convince his wife to go to church next week but realized he didn’t have to. He felt coddled. All he wanted now was a glass of milk and a pickle.